In November 2026, the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) estimated that arbitration determinations closed in 2025 added USD 8.39 billion to the initial payments owed by US health plans in the cases studied. The estimate measures the additional obligation after initial payments and accounts for patient cost sharing. It does not establish how much the arbitration system increased premiums.
Track the cost after the first payment
The federal dispute resolution process under the No Surprises Act can determine payment for qualifying out-of-network services when a plan and provider cannot agree. A determination closed in 2025 may relate to an earlier treatment or initial payment. It may also create an obligation that is settled in cash later. Those distinctions matter when comparing awards with a plan’s annual claims experience.
A self-funded employer can ask its administrator to link the dispute register to the claims ledger, showing initial payments, awards, settlements and the amount still due. Separate decided but unpaid awards from open cases. Estimate the latter using the plan’s own experience and show a range when the data do not support a single figure.
Verify the amount the employer retains
For stop-loss and captive arrangements, check how the contracts treat awards, which period applies and what evidence is needed to support a recovery. Independent non-executive directors on a captive board can ask for a reconciliation between reported disputes, claims reserves and expected recoveries, and challenge any material gap.
The estimate makes a strong case for better reporting at renewal. The practical question is how much of the apparent increase in claims is already recognised, how much may emerge later and which entity will bear it. The plan’s own records are the starting point for that answer.
Sources
PLANSPONSOR: EBRI study and methodology
CMS: federal independent dispute resolution and public-use files
